K-001 Where Does Your Knee Hurt? Possible Causes Based on the Location of Pain
Part 2: Pain Behind the Knee or Throughout the Knee | The Cause May Be Outside the Knee

Medical Review
In Part 1, we explained how we actually examine the knee at Goda Orthopedics and the possible causes of pain at the front, inner side and outer side of the knee.
However, some patients with knee pain tell us, “The back of my knee hurts,” “My whole knee hurts,” or “I am not even sure exactly where it hurts.”
In these situations, examining only the knee joint may not reveal the cause.
This is because conditions outside the knee, such as nerve-related symptoms originating in the lower back, referred pain from the hip and rheumatoid arthritis, can also present as knee pain.
In Part 2, we explain how we assess pain behind the knee or throughout the knee, and how we diagnose knee pain at Goda Orthopedics.
18. Pain Behind the Knee: In Younger Patients, We Also Check the Back of the Meniscus
There are several possible causes when someone says, “The back of my knee hurts.”
In relatively young patients whose knees show no obvious visible deformity, we first check for problems in the back portion of the meniscus.
The meniscus extends not only toward the front of the knee but also toward the back of the joint.
For this reason, damage to its back portion may cause pain deep inside or toward the back of the knee during movements such as bending the knee deeply, squatting, twisting or straightening the knee from a bent position.
However, a meniscal injury cannot be diagnosed from pain behind the knee alone. We assess it by considering tenderness, movement, hands-on examination tests, age, injury history and imaging findings together.
19. Swelling Behind the Knee: Baker’s Cyst
If there is swelling behind the knee with a feeling of tightness, we consider a Baker’s cyst, also called a popliteal cyst.
A Baker’s cyst is a sac-like swelling that forms when excess fluid from the knee joint collects in a bursa behind the knee.
In adults, Baker’s cysts are known to occur more often alongside conditions within the joint, such as knee osteoarthritis or meniscal injuries, rather than on their own.
For this reason, having a Baker’s cyst does not necessarily mean that treating the cyst alone is enough.
We also need to investigate why the amount of joint fluid has increased and identify the underlying condition within the knee joint.
20. A Knee That Does Not Straighten Fully May Feel Tight and Painful at the Back
In middle-aged and older patients who say, “The back of my knee feels tight,” “My knee will not straighten fully,” or “My whole knee feels heavy,” we first check whether the knee can straighten completely.
If restricted knee extension persists for a long time, structures such as the joint capsule at the back of the knee may become stiff, causing a tight, pulling pain behind the knee.
In this situation, the problem is not necessarily confined to the back of the knee. Several underlying conditions may coexist, including knee osteoarthritis, meniscal degeneration or injury, joint effusion and stiffness due to contracture throughout the joint.
Pain behind the knee may not be explained by a single condition; several problems can overlap.
21. Muscles and Tendons Can Also Cause Pain Behind the Knee
Behind the knee, there are several muscles and tendons as well as the joint itself. One example is the biceps femoris, which is one of the hamstring muscles.
Pain originating in a muscle or tendon may be reproduced by contracting the muscle, bending the knee, performing sports movements or pressing on the affected area.
Is the cause inside the joint, or is it a muscle or tendon? The movements that bring on pain also provide important information during the examination.
22. Sudden Swelling Extending Into the Calf May Not Be Just a Knee Problem
If a Baker’s cyst ruptures, pain and swelling can develop suddenly from behind the knee down into the calf.
These symptoms can resemble those of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and other conditions. Medical literature also recognizes that a ruptured Baker’s cyst can cause sudden pain and swelling behind the knee and in the lower leg, making it necessary to distinguish it from DVT.
If one calf suddenly becomes swollen or painful, seek urgent medical assessment the same day rather than assuming it is fluid from the knee. If leg pain or swelling is accompanied by shortness of breath or chest pain, seek emergency help immediately. Call 119 in Japan for an ambulance; do not drive yourself.
23. Some Patients Say, “My Whole Knee Hurts”
When we ask patients with knee pain where it hurts, some indicate the whole knee by cupping their hands around it.
Patients themselves may be unable to tell exactly where the pain is coming from.
In this situation, taking a detailed history is particularly important.
We ask whether it hurts with movement or even at rest, whether there has been a fall or a blow, whether the pain began suddenly, whether there has been a recent fever, whether only one knee hurts, and whether the other knee or other joints are also painful.
A suddenly very painful, hot or swollen knee needs urgent assessment the same day, even without a fever. Joint infection is one possible cause and cannot be excluded by the absence of fever. NHS: Septic arthritis.
24. If Both Knees or Several Joints Hurt, We Also Consider Systemic Diseases
It is important to establish whether only the knee is painful or whether several joints are affected.
For example, if both knees are swollen, other joints such as the fingers or toes are also painful, there is marked morning stiffness, or there is fever or general fatigue, we also consider inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis.
Although rheumatoid arthritis often begins in the small joints of the hands and feet, it can also affect larger joints. Symmetrical swelling in several joints is one of its important features.
Knee pain does not necessarily mean that the problem is limited to the knee.
25. Nerve-Related Symptoms From the Lower Back Can Feel Like Knee Pain
If a thorough examination of the knee finds no clear tenderness and a patient indicates a broad area from the thigh to the lower leg, saying, “This whole area hurts,” we also consider nerve-related symptoms originating in the lower back.
At Goda Orthopedics, we sometimes ask patients, “Please touch the places that actually hurt to show us where they are.”
Pain that extends broadly from around the knee into the lower leg, rather than being confined to one point along the joint line, can be a clue to a nerve-related cause.
26. L4, L5 and S1 Cannot Be Identified From the Location of Pain Alone
In general neurological descriptions, L3 and L4 involvement may cause sensory symptoms from the front of the thigh to around the knee, L5 involvement along the outer side of the leg toward the top of the foot, and S1 involvement along the back of the thigh and lower leg toward the outer side of the foot.
However, radicular pain does not always follow the textbook distribution of a dermatome, the area of skin supplied by a particular nerve root.
In particular, it is difficult to distinguish L4, L5 and S1 accurately from the location of pain alone. When assessing which nerve root is involved, we need to consider not only pain but also the distribution of numbness or tingling, muscle strength and tendon reflexes.
For this reason, we do not make definitive statements such as, “Pain on the outer side must be L5.”
Seek emergency care immediately if back or leg symptoms are accompanied by new difficulty passing urine, loss of bladder or bowel control, numbness around the groin or anus, or rapidly worsening leg weakness. Do not wait until the next day.
27. Hip Problems Can Also Cause Knee Pain
If no clear abnormality is found in the knee itself, the hip also needs to be examined.
Hip conditions often cause pain in the groin or the front of the thigh and may restrict hip movement.
Research has reported that pain originating in the hip can radiate as far as the knee, or even farther down the leg.
Therefore, we also consider referred pain from the hip when examining the knee does not explain the pain, hip movement is restricted, or there is also pain in the groin or thigh.
As general orthopedic clinicians, it is important that we do not stop our diagnostic assessment after examining only the knee.
28. We Also Check for Knee Instability
During a knee examination, it is important to assess instability as well as tenderness and range of motion.
We check for instability in the inward and outward directions, known as varus and valgus instability, and in the forward and backward directions.
Especially after a sports injury or a fall, we consider possible injuries to the anterior cruciate ligament, posterior cruciate ligament, medial collateral ligament and lateral collateral ligament.
In addition to where it hurts, symptoms such as “My knee feels wobbly,” “It feels as if it will give way,” or “I cannot brace myself on it” are important diagnostic clues.
29. We Compare the Examination Findings With X-Rays to Investigate the Cause
At Goda Orthopedics, patients with knee pain first have an initial history taken by a nurse. Depending on their symptoms, they may then have X-rays taken before seeing the doctor.
However, we do not make a diagnosis from X-rays alone.
We observe how patients walk into the examination room, review their history and ask further questions to fill in any missing information.
We then assess the knee’s appearance, kneecap, joint effusion, range of motion, tenderness and instability, and compare the examination findings with the X-rays.
If there is clear knee osteoarthritis that is consistent with the examination findings, we explain it to the patient while showing them their X-rays.
30. We Do Not Say, “It Is Just Old Age, So Nothing Can Be Done”
When we show X-rays to patients with knee osteoarthritis, some say, “This is because of my age, isn’t it?” or “I am getting older, so nothing can be done, right?”
At Goda Orthopedics, however, we generally do not explain the condition by saying, “You are getting older, so nothing can be done.”
Aging is certainly an important risk factor for knee osteoarthritis. However, several factors are involved, including age, body weight, previous injuries, knee alignment, genetic factors and years of loading on the joint.
In other words, aging does not cause everyone’s knees to develop the same changes.
31. We Think of Them as Knees That Have Worked Hard for You Over the Years
You do not need to look at changes in your knee and give up, thinking, “I am old now, so nothing can be done.”
At Goda Orthopedics, we sometimes explain to patients, “These changes have developed in a knee that has worked hard for you over the years.”
These knees have supported your body through years of work, walking and everyday life.
Having structural changes does not mean that treatment is pointless.
Even if it is difficult to reverse those changes completely, treatments are available to reduce pain, improve movement, maintain muscle strength, make walking easier and make daily life more comfortable.
Rather than simply putting it down to age, it is important to work together on ways to reduce the pain you have now.
K-001 Summary: Where It Hurts Is the Starting Point for Diagnosis
The location of pain is very important when assessing knee pain.
However, it is not as simple as saying, “Pain in this location means this disease.”
There are many different tissues at the front, inner side, outer side and back of the knee. When the whole knee hurts, we also need to consider knee osteoarthritis, meniscal injuries, joint contracture, systemic conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, nerve-related symptoms from the lower back and referred pain from the hip.
At Goda Orthopedics, we investigate the cause by combining assessment of walking, history-taking, visual examination, palpation, range of motion, hands-on tests and instability testing with imaging, rather than looking only at where it hurts.
Telling your doctor where it hurts and which movements bring on the pain provides very important clues to the diagnosis.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Location of Knee Pain
Q1. If the inner side of my knee hurts, does that mean I have knee osteoarthritis?
Not necessarily. The medial meniscus, medial collateral ligament, pes anserinus region and subchondral bone can also be the source of pain. We make a diagnosis by considering age, injury history, the location of tenderness and X-rays together.
Q2. If the back of my knee hurts, is it a Baker’s cyst?
A Baker’s cyst is one possible cause, but problems in the back of the meniscus, joint contracture, and muscle or tendon problems can also cause pain behind the knee.
Q3. If I have a Baker’s cyst, does that mean my meniscus is damaged too?
In adults, Baker’s cysts often accompany conditions inside the joint, such as meniscal injuries or knee osteoarthritis, so we assess the inside of the knee joint as well as the cyst.
Q4. If my X-ray is normal, does that mean there is nothing wrong with my knee?
Not necessarily. Plain X-rays alone cannot adequately assess the menisci, ligaments or cartilage. Conditions such as subchondral insufficiency fractures may also be unclear on early X-rays.
Q5. Can a problem in the lower back cause knee pain?
Yes. Symptoms arising from lumbar nerve roots may cause pain, numbness or tingling around the knee or elsewhere in the leg. However, the nerve root involved cannot be identified from the location of pain alone.
Q6. Can a hip condition cause knee pain?
Yes. Hip conditions, particularly hip osteoarthritis, can cause referred pain in the knee. If a knee examination alone does not explain the cause, we also examine the hip.
Q7. What do you consider when both knees hurt?
In addition to knee osteoarthritis, we consider inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, particularly if other joints are also swollen or painful.
Q8. Is treatment pointless because knee osteoarthritis is caused by age?
No. Age is one risk factor, but knee osteoarthritis involves several factors, including body weight, previous injuries and alignment. Even when structural changes are present, treatments are available to improve pain and function.
Related Articles
- Where Does Your Knee Hurt? Part 1: Front, Inner and Outer Knee Pain
- Knee Pain with Movement: Stairs and Standing Up
- How Doctors Examine and Diagnose Knee Pain
- L-003: What Is Lumbar Disc Herniation? Part 1 (Japanese)
- L-004: What Is Lumbar Spinal Stenosis? Part 1 (Japanese)
About the Medical Review
This article is based on Dr. Goda’s clinical experience and examination procedures in general orthopedic practice as its primary source. It does not present a specialist opinion from a knee specialist.
Medical descriptions concerning diagnosis, nerve-related symptoms, Baker’s cysts, knee osteoarthritis and referred pain have been checked against standard medical literature and academic resources in orthopedics and rheumatology.
In particular, the article follows research findings in explaining that nerve root involvement should not be determined solely from the location of L4, L5 or S1 pain, that hip conditions can present as knee pain, and that Baker’s cysts are associated with several conditions within the joint, including osteoarthritis as well as meniscal injuries.
Key References and Academic Resources
- Baker’s Cyst: Diagnostic and Surgical Considerations. Sports Health. 2015.
- Posterior Knee Pain. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine. 2010.
- Lumbar Radicular Pain. BJA Education. 2022.
- Pain patterns and descriptions in patients with radicular pain: Does the pain necessarily follow a specific dermatome? Chiropractic & Osteopathy. 2009.
- American College of Rheumatology. Rheumatoid Arthritis – Patient Information.
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS). Management of Osteoarthritis of the Knee – Clinical Practice Guideline.
- Hip osteoarthritis: where is the pain? Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England. 2004.
Additional safety references: NHS: DVT; NHS: Back pain.
Reviewer Profiles
Chairman, GOZEN Medical Corporation
Orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science
Director, Kita 7-jo Goda Orthopedics
Orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science; occupational physician; Japan Sport Association-certified sports doctor
Director, Iwamizawa Goda Orthopedics
Orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science; Japanese Society for Replacement Arthroplasty-certified physician; Japan Sport Association-certified sports doctor
Article Information
Article number: K-001
Article title: Where Does Your Knee Hurt? Possible Causes Based on the Location of Pain
Article section: Part 2 / Pain behind the knee, pain throughout the knee and referred pain from outside the knee
Series: Goda Orthopedics’ Guide to Knee Pain
Medical review: Taketoshi Goda / Takuro Sasaki / Naoki Seito
Original Japanese publication date: Sunday, October 11, 2026
This article was translated from the original Japanese using AI. Not all staff at Kita 7-jo Goda Orthopedics are fluent in English, but we make every effort to communicate with you and help you feel understood.



