Why We Continue In-House Dispensing

Illustration of a patient receiving medicine at the clinic

Considering how patients receive their medicines and the burden this places on them

Reviewed by: Taketoshi Goda, Takuro Sasaki, and Naoki Seito

At Goda Orthopedics, we dispense medicines in-house, so patients can receive their medicines where they have their consultation. We want to make it easier to continue treatment by considering the effort of traveling to a pharmacy, waiting times, and patients’ financial burden.

Outside pharmacies also have important roles: pharmacists explain how to take medicines and check medicines prescribed by multiple medical institutions. Neither approach has only advantages. This article explains the differences between the two systems and why our clinic continues to dispense medicines in-house.

1 Differences between in-house and outside-pharmacy dispensing

In-house dispensing

Patients receive their prescribed medicines at the hospital or clinic where they have their consultation. Everything from the consultation to collecting medicines can be completed at the same medical institution.

Outside-pharmacy dispensing

The medical institution where patients have their consultation issues a prescription, and patients collect their medicines at an outside pharmacy. There, a pharmacist checks the prescription, dispenses the medicines, and explains how to take them. If anything in the prescription needs clarification, the pharmacist contacts the prescribing doctor.

Checking the medicines prescribed and possible interactions is essential with in-house dispensing, too. Wherever patients receive their medicines, prescribing and dispensing must comply with the relevant laws and the arrangements required for each facility. [1]

In-house and outside-pharmacy dispensing at a glance

This comparison describes how patients generally receive medicines after an in-person consultation. Arrangements vary depending on the facility’s practices, the patient’s condition, and the services used.

Point of comparison In-house dispensing Outside-pharmacy dispensing
Where medicines are collected The medical institution where the consultation took place Generally, an outside pharmacy
Travel and check-in Medicines are collected at the same facility, without traveling elsewhere to collect them Patients usually travel from the medical institution to a pharmacy and check in there as well
How payments are made Payment for the consultation and medicines is made at the clinic A separate payment at the pharmacy is added to the payment at the clinic
Medication checks The prescription, medicines from other institutions, possible interactions, and other details are checked within the medical institution In addition to the doctor’s prescription, the pharmacy’s pharmacist also checks the medicines, possible interactions, and other details
What to include when comparing costs Include in-house prescribing, dispensing, and other charges, not just the medicines themselves Add together the costs at both the clinic and the pharmacy

The steps involved in receiving medicines

In-house dispensing Outside-pharmacy dispensing
Consultation at the same medical institution
↓
Medicines are prepared and explained, then collected
Everything, including payment, is completed within the institution
Consultation and prescription issued at the medical institution
↓ Usually followed by a visit to a pharmacy
Check-in, checks, dispensing, and explanations at the pharmacy
Medicines are collected and a separate payment is made at the pharmacy

Outside-pharmacy dispensing may also involve online medication counseling or delivery services. The diagram above shows the usual process for an in-person pharmacy visit; it does not mean that everyone must travel to a pharmacy.

The order of check-in, payment, and medicine collection varies by facility. Waiting times and relative costs cannot be determined from this process alone.

2 Reducing winter travel and repeated procedures

One reason we value in-house dispensing is our wish to reduce the burden of having to travel to another place after a consultation.

In Hokkaido’s winters, even stepping outside can mean facing bitter cold. For people with knee or lower back pain, walking along snowy or icy roads to a pharmacy is no small burden. We also believe that being able to collect medicines where the consultation took place matters when someone is feeling unwell.

At an outside pharmacy, patients need to check in again, wait for their medicines to be prepared, and pay. The time involved varies with the pharmacy’s location and how busy it is, but patients need to allow time beyond the consultation itself.

With in-house dispensing, patients do not need to travel to another facility to collect their medicines, and payment can be completed at our clinic. There may still be a wait while medicines are prepared, but we value being able to reduce the number of journeys and procedures involved.

Making it easier to raise questions about medicines during the consultation

Please tell us during your consultation if you have experienced problems after taking a medicine or have difficulty taking it. Alongside your symptoms, we ask how you have been getting on with your medicines and use this information when considering your prescription.

Dr. Goda also sees the connection between the consultation and explanations and discussions about medicines as an advantage of in-house dispensing. We aim to provide care in which patients feel able to ask about anything they do not understand, so they do not go home with unanswered questions about their medicines.

3 Checking medicines from other institutions, even with in-house dispensing

Some patients receiving orthopedic care are also prescribed medicines by internal medicine departments or other services. We therefore cannot decide on a prescription by considering only the medicines we prescribe.

Dr. Goda places importance on asking patients which medicines they currently use and checking prescriptions from other institutions. For example, if another medical institution has already prescribed a stomach medicine, we check whether it is necessary for our clinic to prescribe a similar medicine as well. This does not mean stopping all stomach medicines across the board. Decisions depend on the medicine and its purpose.

During consultations, quite a few patients cannot immediately identify the medicines they take. It is fine if you do not remember their names. Please show us your medication record book or something else that identifies your medicines at your consultation. Please also tell us about any over-the-counter medicines or supplements you use.

Not relying solely on information-sharing systems

Systems such as online health insurance eligibility verification and electronic prescriptions are being developed to allow medical institutions and pharmacies to check medication information. However, the information available depends on factors such as the facility’s implementation status and the patient’s consent. Support for registering information on in-house dispensing and similar arrangements in the electronic prescription system is also progressing. [2]

Even with these systems, it is not always possible to obtain a complete picture of a patient’s medicine use automatically. Medication record books and what patients tell us are also important. Please let us know, for example, if you also receive medicines from another hospital or if your medicines have recently changed.

Pharmacists at outside pharmacies also play an important role

At outside pharmacies, pharmacists check for duplicate medicines and interactions from a perspective separate from the doctor’s, and explain how to take the medicines. For people attending multiple medical institutions, being able to seek ongoing advice about their medicines is another advantage. Our clinic’s choice of in-house dispensing does not mean we dismiss these roles.

4 Do not compare costs using only the clinic’s bill

With in-house dispensing, the cost of medicines is paid together with the other charges at the clinic. Looking only at the amount paid at the clinic can therefore make it seem more expensive than a visit to a medical institution that uses outside-pharmacy dispensing. Dr. Goda says that this difference can sometimes lead to the misunderstanding that “Goda Orthopedics is expensive.”

With outside-pharmacy dispensing, patients pay at the pharmacy separately from the medical institution. When comparing costs, it is important to look at the combined amount paid at the medical institution and pharmacy, rather than the clinic’s bill alone. If the tests and care provided also differ, the total alone cannot tell you how the dispensing methods compare.

Include the cost of medicines, prescribing, and dispensing

The cost of receiving medicines includes not only the medicines themselves, but also charges related to prescribing, dispensing, checking medicines, and explaining how to use them. The combination of these charges differs between in-house and outside-pharmacy dispensing. [3]

In-house dispensing also involves prescribing fees, dispensing fees, and other charges. With outside-pharmacy dispensing, the medical institution bills for issuing the prescription and other applicable items, while the pharmacy bills for dispensing, pharmaceutical management, medication counseling, and other services. Pharmacy charges also cover work that supports the safe use of medicines.

Our wish to keep patients’ out-of-pocket costs as low as possible is another reason we continue to dispense in-house. However, we cannot say universally that in-house dispensing is always cheaper or that every patient’s costs will be reduced to a particular fraction.

A fair comparison requires the same types and quantities of medicines, number of prescription days, and patient copayment rate, while taking into account the items billed by both the medical institution and the pharmacy. It is important not to compare the cost of medicines alone with a total that includes medicines plus various other charges.

5 Healthcare costs are supported by more than patients’ payments

The out-of-pocket amount paid at the counter varies according to age, income, and other factors. Some people pay 30%, but this does not apply to everyone. Nor is everything beyond the patient’s share paid entirely from national government funds.

According to the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare’s National Medical Care Expenditure for fiscal year 2023, insurance premiums accounted for 50.2% of funding, national and local public funds for 37.5%, and patient payments for 11.8%. Public funding comprised 24.8% from the national treasury and 12.7% from local governments. These are shares of total healthcare expenditure, not the copayment rates of individual patients. [4]

Dr. Goda believes it is important to consider not only the amount paid at the counter, but also the share supported by insurance premiums and public funds, and to think about a system that allows people to continue receiving necessary care without undue strain.

6 Why we continue in-house dispensing despite the burden on the clinic

We do not continue in-house dispensing to increase profits from medicines. While taking on the work of purchasing medicines and managing stock and expiry dates, we value reducing the effort patients spend on travel and payments.

To continue in-house dispensing, the clinic must purchase medicines, manage stock and expiry dates, and ensure that staff are available to prepare medicines. Stocking the necessary medicines entails upfront costs, and unused medicines and expiry dates also require careful management.

Dr. Goda feels that, if only these operational demands were considered, outside-pharmacy dispensing would reduce some of the clinic’s burden. Even so, choosing in-house dispensing out of consideration for patients’ travel, procedures, and financial burden is part of the conviction behind how we run our clinic.

“At least for as long as I am running the clinic, I don’t think I will change our in-house dispensing.” This is how Dr. Goda expresses his view. It is a choice he wants to continue for patients’ benefit, not a rejection of medical institutions that choose outside-pharmacy dispensing or of the role of pharmacies.

Understanding the differences between in-house and outside-pharmacy dispensing can be an opportunity to think about your own treatment and medicines. Alongside where you collect them, please pay attention to what each medicine is for, how to take it, and whom to consult if you have a problem.

At Goda Orthopedics, we want to look beyond treatment itself to how patients attend appointments, receive their medicines, and continue treatment in their daily lives.

Frequently asked questions

With in-house dispensing, do I pay only for the medicines themselves?

No. In-house dispensing also includes prescribing, dispensing, and other charges. The actual amount depends on the medicines, the number of prescription days, billing conditions, and your copayment rate.

Should I tell you about medicines from other hospitals?

Yes. This is important for checking for duplicate medicines and possible interactions. Please show us your medication record book or similar information, and tell us everything you currently use, including over-the-counter medicines and supplements.

Can I stop a medicine myself if it seems to duplicate another?

Do not stop or change medicines on your own. Please consult the prescribing doctor or a pharmacist. Even medicines with similar names or purposes may be necessary for your treatment.

Are there advantages to outside pharmacies, too?

Yes. An important advantage is that pharmacists check prescriptions and medicine use, and patients can ask about how to take medicines and possible interactions. Whether dispensing is in-house or at an outside pharmacy, checks are needed to help ensure medicines are used safely.

About the medical reviewers

Taketoshi Goda

Chairman, GOZEN Medical Corporation
Board-certified orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science

Takuro Sasaki

Director, Kita 7-jo Goda Orthopedics
Board-certified orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science; occupational physician; Japan Sport Association-certified sports doctor

Naoki Seito

Director, Iwamizawa Goda Orthopedics
Board-certified orthopedic specialist; Doctor of Medical Science; certified physician of the Japanese Society for Replacement Arthroplasty; Japan Sport Association-certified sports doctor

About this article

This article provides general information about how patients receive medicines and explains our clinic’s approach to care. Individual prescriptions and costs vary according to the care provided, billing conditions, changes to the system, and other factors. Please consult the prescribing doctor or a pharmacist before changing or stopping medicines.

References

[1] Article 19 of Japan’s Pharmacists Act. Exceptions permitting dispensing by physicians and others.
https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/335AC0000000146

[2] Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare: Electronic Prescriptions. Information sharing and support for in-house dispensing and related arrangements.
https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/denshishohousen.html

[3] Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare: Fiscal Year 2026 Medical Fee Revision. Materials for checking billing items for medical care and dispensing.
https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/newpage_67729.html

[4] Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare: National Medical Care Expenditure, Fiscal Year 2023, Summary of Results, Table 3: National Medical Care Expenditure by Funding Source.
https://www.mhlw.go.jp/toukei/saikin/hw/k-iryohi/23/dl/R05kekka.pdf

This article was translated from the original Japanese using AI. Not all staff at Kita 7-jo Goda Orthopedics are fluent in English, but we make every effort to communicate with you and help you feel understood.

Please feel free to contact us.

Hours Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Weekends
Holidays
AM 9:00-12:00
AM9:00-12:00
● ● ● ● ● -
PM 2:00-6:00
PM 2:00-6:00
● ● - ● ● -
                               

Closed: Wednesday afternoons, weekends and national holidays
*Rehabilitation is available from 8:30am to 6:00pm